*** VD 9 Commentary Thread ***

[johnnya24]

No I went back and look at my H Zimmerman and his stats are different for both career and season. Slasher Lyons also is different. I would suggest everyone look up there picks and note them

Add george Davis season and career stat different

... and that throws another spanner in the works, because those are not 1870's players.

Zimmerman's PA's jumped by 150, but his AB's remained the same. 5 extra RBI's. Weird.

[johnnya24]

Would it be possible for everyone to go through their team, and confirm that the stats for any player before 1920 tally with BR.com ... and make a post to confirm their team is checked so I can tick them off, if there are differences, highlight the players and I will update the SS.

Also, if you are thinking of picking a player from before 1920, could you do a check with BR.com and make sure it's correct.

Bold = Fixed HITTERS

1 TS Garp (minor changes to Latham)
2 Revo (minor changes to Cap Anson)
3 DMT
4 Frae
5 Heyelander
6 Feral Slasher
7 Hacko (minor changes to Van Haltren, Zimmerman, G Davis/1897)
8 mjl (minor changes to Wagner/1899/1912)
9 Johnny (minor changes to Delahanty, Zimmer and Tucker)
10 Diablo
11 Controller J
12 Long John

EDIT: most of these errors seem to be compiling errors. I'm guessing counting wasn't top to the list of desired skills on these job application forms (says the person who uses a calculator for everything).

[Long John]

I won't be able to do this until tomorrow.

[heyelander]

I'll look later tonight

[hacko]

Quinn and Welch had a few small changes too

[johnnya24]

Quinn and Welch had a few small changes too

Should mention that I'm doing the hitters first ... will get back to the pitchers after.

[Long John]

I looked through mine tonight. Some minor changes, but nothing ridiculous. Will post tomorrow.

[mjl]

Honus Wagner: -1 career RBI
King Kelly: no change
Eddie Plank: no change
Mordecai Brown: no change
Harry Heilmann: +1 career RBI
and the Spalding changes already noted.

[Long John]

Tris Speaker: +2 career RBI
George Bradley's career line changed, but not significantly - +51Ks most notably. ERA and WHIP went up a bit.

2940.0	3009	795	196	671	171	347	2	2.43	1.090

Art Nehf: +1 career Sv

PAs changed for a number of my older hitters, but nothing that would affect our deliberations.

[hacko]

bag.jpg

Happy Birthday eld

[frae]

Sorry went out to enjoy having today off and was in no shape to pick last night. Finally having coffee, pick up soon.

[hacko]

drunk_people_640_43.jpg

Sorry went out to enjoy having today off and was in no shape to pick last night. Finally having coffee, pick up soon.

fixed

[frae]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]661[/ATTACH]

fixed

That is how I felt after picking Inky, yuck.

[The Feral Slasher]

Lyons plus on career run and plus one career RBI
Dahlen - NC
McCormick - NC
Mathewson -NC

[heyelander]

Joss - NC
Clarkson - NC
O'Rourke -
Less ABs = 8503
Less Hits = 2639
Less BA = .310
More BB = 413
More SB = 229
More RBI = 1208