What price for the Top 3 in last years auction?

[Gregg]

So now the question becomes, If all of these guys (in each scenario) were on your team, which would you throw back?

[SlideRule]

Well, in my specific scenario, I wouldn't keep any of them. (other than Cabrera at $35 again if he were mine to keep.)

[tinitoys]

12 team nl-only, 25 man roster, 280 cap

kemp 52 (6th)
upton 45 (2nd)
holliday 44(3rd)
tulo 43 (8th)
h. ramirez 42 (4th)
r. zimmerman 40 (9th)
reyes 40 (2nd)
bourn 40 (3rd)
cliff lee 40 (1st)
halladay 39 (5th)

votto was a keeper at 15

throw everybody back!!!

[Tuna]

So now the question becomes, If all of these guys (in each scenario) were on your team, which would you throw back?

I'm keeping Braun at 45, our inflation rate usually is fairly constant, in the 25-30% range (12 team $260). The highest, Votto & Kemp at 49, I believe will be throw back.