Rank these prospects for 2017 and for 2018?

[scottw]

Jorge Alfaro
Jacob Nottingham
Roman Quinn
Nick Williams
JP Crawford
Robert Stephenson
Amir Garrett
Ian Happ
Alen Hansen
Albert Almora
Zach Davies
Zach Eflin

NL-only, 12-team keeper league. I had a lousy team last year, made trades of high-value guys and came away with 12 very nice prospects as well as some more established players, too. Obviously, with so many, I have to make some decisions based on 1 year, 2 year, etc. readiness to do well in the bigs. I can keep up to 5 and maintain their rookie salary exemption [$280. cap], but I may have to carry 1-2 more if I can't get value in trades this winter. I have a couple tiers in my mind, but I would appreciate input from the board. I am not looking for any particular category, either, although speed and power will be in short supply. I need everything. Thanks!

[Moonlight J]

Jorge Alfaro
Roman Quinn
JP Crawford
Ian Happ

my favorite 4 (in no order)

[scottw]

Jorge Alfaro
Roman Quinn
JP Crawford
Ian Happ

my favorite 4 (in no order)

----------and 3 of 4 are Phils! Woulda thunk?

[The Dane]

Jorge Alfaro- Meh. To each his own, but I generally stay away from ML catchers.
Jacob Nottingham- See: Alfaro, Jorge
Roman Quinn- I like him, but damn, that's a LOT of DL time for a kid. He has a bad wrist and concussion problems. Very risky.
Nick Williams- Wait and see. Upside is still there, but last year was a big disappointment no matter how you look at it.
JP Crawford- I like him, but hes probably a better RL SS than a fantasy one. Like the polar opposite of Trevor Story. Useful probably on a fantasy roster, but won't generate huge counting stats.
Robert Stephenson- Love this guy. He may suck for another year or so, but really like his #2 potential.
Amir Garrett- Also like, but not sure of how much good he'll be on a fantasy roster in the short term.
Ian Happ- The #1 name on his list.
Alen Hansen- If only he had a place to play, he might actually be worth something. He could probably give 10HRs/25SBs and a shitty OBP for PIT today.
Albert Almora- Not high on him at all. Seems pretty pedestrian to me.
Zach Davies- THIS is an interesting pitcher. Ceiling is not very high, but he's shown he can pitch in the majors, go through rough patches and come through them. I think he's a definite keeper. Get your Ks and Ws somewhere else though.
Zach Eflin- I think he'll end up a middling middle reliever when all is said and done.

[scottw]

Thanks, Dane. As I am based in Philly, it helps to get unfiltered opinion, as 5 of the 12 are Phils.
Anyone else?

[chancellor]

Happ
Crawford
Alfaro
~~
Davies
Quinn
Stephenson

Davies is limited upside but looks solid as a #3/4 SP. Quinn has higher upside, but I just don't think he'll hold up.

Agree with The Dane on Happ. He's the #1 on the list. Want higher risk, but potentially higher reward, go with Alfaro next.

[scottw]

anyone else care to chime in? Thanks so far!

[Sharky]

Happ
Crawford
Almora
Williams

[scottw]

Happ
Crawford
Almora
Williams

An interesting order concerning Almora, Sharky. Most seem to feel he would be nearer the bottom of this list than the top. Would you care to explain? I'd be very interested, as I like him, too.
Scottw

[Sharky]

An interesting order concerning Almora, Sharky. Most seem to feel he would be nearer the bottom of this list than the top. Would you care to explain? I'd be very interested, as I like him, too.
Scottw

I'm not a huge Almora fan, but he has a high floor for me. Only Jon Jay stands in his way. So he could be a 10-15 HR, 20SB guy. That was value. And even part time his counting stats could be valuable given team context.