trading - how many pitchers from the same team is too many?

[mjl]

12-team mixed. I'm in second, my only bad categories are AVG and W. Not surprised on AVG, but the wins have been slow to come, although I'm also using more relievers than most teams and trying to make it up with streaming and the streaming has done poorly so far.

My staff: Kluber, Harvey, Hammel, various SP (currently Eovaldi, Wada, Buchholz), Chapman, Miller, Soria

Should I be willing to trade one of my closers for Carrasco and Salazar? If so, which one? Miller is at $1, Soria at $4, Chapman is expiring. Should I care that I'd have three Cleveland SPs?

[Boone]

[]. Should I care that I'd have three Cleveland SPs?[]

- In the case of Cleveland, which has some pretty crappy fielders in back of its pitchers, I would say yes. But it depends on what other options you have to do what you need to do.

[heyelander]

2 if they are phillies.

[DMT]

If you can get them both for a closer, I'd definitely go for it. Soria would be the one I'd offer. You will always be able to find another closer later if necessary.

[Hornsby]

Those 3 Cleveland pitchers are NOT too many to have on one staff. Each one is a legitimate stud in his own right, and the K's that they bring to the table mitigate the risks of a crappy defense.

I'd probably offer Chapman, since I like my cake and eat it too...a 1 buck Miller and a 4 buck Soria are both great keepers.

[Erik]

2 if they are phillies.

1 if they are Rockies.

[onejayhawk]

I loaded up with three Tampa Bay pitchers, because the team is unappreciated and the defense is excellent. Miley is toast, but Karns and Odorizzi have been gold. Last year it was the Mets, but I missed getting deGrom. That did not work as well.

J

[overkill94]

I feel like fantasy baseball is a place where you would want as many SP from the same team as possible (as long as they're good) since it decreases the odds of you having your starting pitchers face each other and thus reducing your chance of a win.

[DMT]

I feel like fantasy baseball is a place where you would want as many SP from the same team as possible (as long as they're good) since it decreases the odds of you having your starting pitchers face each other and thus reducing your chance of a win.

Great point.