The RJ 1000: The top 1000 rock classics of all time Discussion Thread

[chancellor]

Zep groupies.

Wait, we can pick more than one per band?

[chancellor]

To foster an explosion of Chance's head, my next 10 picks were going to be Rush songs!

Actually, you’re way behind schedule. 😉

[Gregg]

I know. I already picked 2!

Zep groupies.

[DMT]

Re: Killing in the Name of - One of my faves, but I kind of made my cut-off 1989. If we are going into early 90s for classic rock, it really opens it up for me with all the nirvana, pearl jam, alice in chains etc etc.

But mostly, I wanted to nominate "Laid" by James.

James is one my favorite bands.

[DMT]

Picking just one zep song is a crime!

Same could be said for the Beatles, Stones, Pink Floyd, Bowie, and a band that hasn't even been picked yet!

[Pauly]

I know. I already picked 2!

same!

[Mithrandir]

Picking just one zep song is a crime!

I know. I already picked 2!

[Pauly]

To foster an explosion of Chance's head, my next 10 picks were going to be Rush songs!

lol...not hard to do!

[Mithrandir]

I'm wondering if we should have placed a limit on number of songs a person can pick of a single artist. I'm going to try to limit myself to one but we'll see how it goes.

To foster an explosion of Chance's head, my next 10 picks were going to be Rush songs!

[Pauly]

I'm wondering if we should have placed a limit on number of songs a person can pick of a single artist. I'm going to try to limit myself to one but we'll see how it goes.

Picking just one zep song is a crime!

[DMT]

I'm wondering if we should have placed a limit on number of songs a person can pick of a single artist. I'm going to try to limit myself to one but we'll see how it goes.

[Pauly]

Man do I love White Rabbit.

[Mithrandir]

One of the great crimes in music history is the fact that Marc Bolan never became the massive star that he should have been in the U.S.

[Pauly]

One of the Zep songs I would have hoped to grab a little later was Ten Years Gone, kinda surprised -- pleasantly surprised that is -- that it went before the normal Zep-fair.

fifth overall baby! Best Zep song imo

[Mithrandir]

I joined a "rock classics of all time" draft, not a "classic rock" draft. Vetoing any and all arbitrary period limitations.

If folk wanted hard-rules and limitations, it should have been done beforehand.

Agree with this. I have some post-2000 songs to choose.