Am I offering a fair trade?

[Papa Deuce]

I have yet to propose this. I think it is pretty fair, but of course we don't know the extent of Charles's injury....

I plan to offer Peterson and Josh Gordon for Charles and whatever WR on his team he wants to give up.

The guy is in next to last place in a points only league, and he gets to have 4 keepers for next season.

[revo]

What's the penalty for keepers in this league?

[Pogues]

It would seem most people would think it's too early to make dump trades, but I'm curious to hear the answer to revo's question before I answer.

[Papa Deuce]

What's the penalty for keepers in this league?

none. we can keep 4 players forever. I am in first place..... I have had Julio and Calvin since their rookie years. So, I feel like losing Gordon is something I can handle..... now, whether or not he would even accept the offer is a whole other question... He is in next to last place.

In fact, we all MUST keep 4 players.

[Hornsby]

It's fair, but I really don't see any upside for you in this deal. I think that Peterson and Charles are essentially a wash, both have their warts. And Gordon is a quantum leap ahead of whoever you may get back.

You may want to see about changing the keeper rules...having guys in perpetuity with no penalty really isn't a fair way to run a league, IMO.

[Papa Deuce]

It's fair, but I really don't see any upside for you in this deal. I think that Peterson and Charles are essentially a wash, both have their warts. And Gordon is a quantum leap ahead of whoever you may get back.

You may want to see about changing the keeper rules...having guys in perpetuity with no penalty really isn't a fair way to run a league, IMO.

Meh, we have been doing it for 25 years.

I see my upside as likely getting Charles back sooner than AP plays. Today, I just heard on XM fantasy radio, that Charles' issue appears to be minor..... I did not know that last night, though.

[Hornsby]

Meh, we have been doing it for 25 years.

I see my upside as likely getting Charles back sooner than AP plays. Today, I just heard on XM fantasy radio, that Charles' issue appears to be minor..... I did not know that last night, though.

Short term gain, long term pain for you...

[jwlincy]

The Vikings announced that AP will practice & play this week & Charles sounds like he has a high ankle sprain (likely out 3-4 weeks). I wouldn't make this trade.