Do Giant fans think Eli is a good QB?

[Papa Deuce]

I was chatting online tonight with a Giant fan. He thinks Eli is still a really good QB, but the Giants O-Line is so bad that Eli is bad. Then he went on to say that Eli and Romo are both equally good..... then comes RG3, then Foles. He is really the only Giants fan I know that I talk to, so I have no idea what Giants fans think of him. But I think it is his Eagles hatred that is making him say those things..... he also told me that Detroit will be battling to get into the NFC championship game.

[revo]

Not any more!

He won two Super Bowls for us, so he has a longer leash than most QBs. The Giants didn't sign him to a long-term deal, so this could be his last season in blue. If he plays like he did last night, that would not be surprising.

[ironfist]

I still hear a lot of Giants fans defending him on sports radio, including some of the hosts. Like Revo said, he's got a long leash, but if he keeps playing like this though, that will probably change.

[Erik]

Eli and Romo are equally good ... at throwing interceptions.