Nicks Or Gordon?

[Hornsby]

RJ league, full PPR...I can keep Josh Gordon giving up an 8th round pick, or Hakeem Nicks giving up a 5th. I know that I'm going to lose Gordon for the 1st two games of the season, but I'm constantly worried about the health of Nicks. What say you?

[Erik]

Both look to be pretty much at value, so it depends on whether you are more worried about suspension + knuckleheadism vs. injury history.

[revo]

Tough call, but in a perfect world, Nicks should be the easy keep. So far this pre-season he's fine.

[griswold]

I agree with revo....gotta go with a currently healthy Nicks.

[Friarfan]

I admit to having a bit of a mancrush on Gordon, but Nicks seems to be healthy (although that can change from week-to-week/day-to-day, minute-to-minute). I'd go with Nicks because of his history of success and better QB, but it's close.

[Hornsby]

Being the contrarian that I am, I kept Gordon. Watching Nicks this weekend, he looked slow, and was already somewhat gimpy. Gordon looks tome like he can be another Dez...hopefully, he'll figure life out as well.

[Erik]

It took Dez a while to stop being a knucklehead. We'll see how long it takes Gordon.