Trade for McCoy? Which lineup is best?

[jwlincy]

Looking at making an offer for L. McCoy. Something like: I give Ryan and Richardson OR RGIII and Richardson, I get P. Manning/Luck & McCoy.

Which lineup do you like best?

Standard 14 team league
4pts per passing TDs
1/2pt per reception

[revo]

give Ryan & Richardson, get mcCoy and whoever you think will be better between Manning & Luck this year (won't matter much, they'll only start on your bye week).

[Erik]

I agree with Revo. With 4 point pass TDs, RG3 is probably the one you want to keep, as his legs might make for more consistently high FF scores.

[jwlincy]

A little nervous about the possibility of pairing up 2 rookie QBs (RGIII & Luck) and then hanging my fantasy season on them. Peyton & Ryan are not a good pair either because they both have a Week 7 bye, which means that I'd either have to make another trade or pick up a 3rd QB for Week 7.

I sent the guy an email to see what he'd be willing to give up for Ryan/McCoy or RGIII/McCoy. He has Gronkowski & I have Graham. He has A.J. Green, Roddy White, Lloyd & Wayne at WR and I have Harvin, Colston, Dem. Thomas & Garcon.

[griswold]

I'd wait and see what the owner responds with.

I think you'd get a deal either way (whether you trade Ryan or RGIII)....you may even want to think about trading Garcon for Wayne as an upgrade as well.

[griswold]

I just noticed something....you have Mathews.

Could you trade him instead of T-Rich?

I think a team of Ryan, McCoy, T-Rich, would be the best lineup. That way you eliminate Mr. Injury-Prone.

I guess it depends on how bad the other team wants either Ryan or RGIII.

[revo]

I just noticed something....you have Mathews.

Could you trade him instead of T-Rich?

I think a team of Ryan, McCoy, T-Rich, would be the best lineup. That way you eliminate Mr. Injury-Prone.

I guess it depends on how bad the other team wants either Ryan or RGIII.

Considering the other team has Manning & Luck so is far from desperate for a QB, I can't imagine the other owner would take Mathews over Richardson and still give up McCoy.

[jwlincy]

I just noticed something....you have Mathews.

Could you trade him instead of T-Rich?

I think a team of Ryan, McCoy, T-Rich, would be the best lineup. That way you eliminate Mr. Injury-Prone.

I guess it depends on how bad the other team wants either Ryan or RGIII.

I sent him an email yesterday to ask if he'd consider dealing McCoy. He responded and said that he may be interested in a 2 for 2 deal where he got a QB and a guy like Richardson. I responded and asked if he had a specific offer that he liked, haven't heard back from him. I was just getting my ducks in a row so I can determine which offer I like the best. That way when he responds, I can already know what deal I like best.