Big Trade Offer

[jwlincy]

I just submitted the following offer in my 14 team 0.5PPR league:

I give:
M. Ryan (also have Wilson)
McCoy
Garcon
Spiller

I get:
Newton
Bernard (already had his bye)
Calvin
J. Bell

The other team has:

QB: Newton, Manziel
RB: Bernard, Sproles, J. Bell, K. Davis
WR: Calvin, T. Williams, Bowe, Cooper
TE: Gates, Witten
K: Crosby
DEF: CIN

Is this a good trade for my team (in signature)? And does it have any chance to get accepted?

[swampdragon]

It is just one source but
http://fantasynews.cbssports.com/fan...y-trade-values

M. Ryan 26 - Newton 9
McCoy 27 - Bernard 31
Garcon 16 - Calvin 33
Spiller 13 - Joique Bell 16

according to that chart it seems like a lot to give up for upgrading to Newton - I don't see why he would do it.

[jwlincy]

It is just one source but
http://fantasynews.cbssports.com/fan...y-trade-values

M. Ryan 26 - Newton 9
McCoy 27 - Bernard 31
Garcon 16 - Calvin 33
Spiller 13 - Joique Bell 16

according to that chart it seems like a lot to give up for upgrading to Newton - I don't see why he would do it.

He's currently 1-4 and projected to lose this week which would drop him to 1-5. He's starting Newton, Bernard, T. Williams, Cooper & Sproles this week.

I already checked the trade chart and knew that I was getting the better end according that the chart. I was debating whether I should drop the Spiller/J. Bell part of the trade.

If you look at the season averages it breaks down to Ryan (21.17), McCoy (9.04), Garcon (9.36) & Spiller (8.92) or 48.49 total versus Newton (14.88), Bernard (16.38), Calvin (11.96) & J. Bell (7.75) or 50.97 total. Both Newton & Calvin has under performed on his side and McCoy & Garcon on my side.

[revo]

he might do it, considering Calvin may be shut down for a week or two.

[jwlincy]

He rejected the offer although he said that it intrigued him. He said that he didn't know if he wants to give up Bernard.

Should I let him think about it over the weekend?
Or should I just offer Ryan/Garcon for Newton/Calvin or Ryan/Garcon/Spiller for Newton/Calvin/J. Bell?
Or should I offer up the same trade but put Wilson in there instead of Ryan? So Wilson/McCoy/Garcon/Spiller for Newton/Bernard/Calvin/J. Bell.

As far as the Newton/Calvin for Ryan/Garcon offer goes, its basically whether I'd rather have 2 strong QB options to stream each week (Ryan & Wilson) or 2 RB/WR options (McCoy & Calvin when he gets healthy).

I need a bye week sub for Week 7 (McCoy), Week 11 (Murray) & Week 12 (A. Brown). So I had Garcon, Spiller & Hyde to choose from. With the trade, I'd likely be looking at Spiller or Hyde (or a FA) for Week 7 since Calvin likely wouldn't be trustworthy yet. Then I'd probably have Calvin available for sure in Week 11 & 12. But I'd likely be starting Wilson every week (with Newton backing him up).

What say you fellow Junkies?

[jwlincy]

Is Spiller & Garcon too much to offer for Calvin? Or not enough? I think Ryan, Garcon & Spiller is too much for Newton & Calvin. Just trying to come up with some other offers that don't include Bernard since he sounds like he doesn't want to trade him.

[Pogues]

Is there any QB starter on the WW? Just wondering if you could deal away Ryan in the trade and not get Newton back, helping you get what you really want.

[jwlincy]

Yes. Glennon, Tannehill, Orton, Fitzpatrick types though. If I made the deal without getting Newton, I'd probably just roll with Wilson & no backup since he's already had his bye.