Quick AL Trade Help

[virgonomic]

AL 5x5, Team in Sig. Trade deadline is tomorrow.

A dumper wants Porcello 11 or Pineda 8 (both for 2015 only - we have 1-year keepers).

He is offering Paxton 3X and Street 5 (30 in 2015).

I can gain a point in SV and 2-3 in WHIP. The team ahead of me has Rodney/Nathan. I have Perkins/Feliz (acquired today).

I am in third, 3.5 out of first. I can gain a few points in WHIP and AVG, which are not easy.

Is getting Street enough to trade a decent keeper? Which one should I move?

[overkill94]

Those aren't great keepers anyway - I'd do it. I'm a sucker for Pineda's upside so I'd rather trade Porcello.

[virgonomic]

His original offer involved Porcello so I put it out there.