In a 12 team mixed, what do you think of this dump trade

[mike9289]

League can keep guys for 3 years, no extensions. Team A traded Donaldson (B $3) for Adam Jones ($39) and Beltre (C $24, can't be kept).

[Sour Masher]

I think it is a good return for the dumper. A $3 Donaldson is a great keeper.

[Hammer]

If I had Donaldson I would've wanted a little more but that's a solid hauls.

[cardboardbox]

good deal for both sides

[mike9289]

Thanks guys. I was the dumper in this trade. My league mates don't understand dumping. Got the usual complaining and objections because I didn't get enough for my 2 studs. 1st 3 responses say that the Donaldson side isn't the side they should be worried about.
Trade passed the vote luckily. Now offers are rolling in. 1st one is Springer A $3 for Grienke $29 and Lester $18. I promised to give everybody a chance to get offers in but I'm dying to click accept.

[Sour Masher]

Yeah, that was a great deal for you, and I doubt anyone will top Springer at A $3. Although, in my league, I offered Springer for Scherzer and Lester and got shot down quickly.

[mike9289]

Yeah, that was a great deal for you, and I doubt anyone will top Springer at A $3. Although, in my league, I offered Springer for Scherzer and Lester and got shot down quickly.

Was offered Gattis B $3 for those same 2 sps (Lester and Grienke). Wonder if Springer's slump caused that guy to turn him down.

[Sour Masher]

Gattis for those two is a joke. No, he wanted Springer, a lot, he just wanted more. He wanted Shelby Miller and Jorge Soler too in that deal. I didn't want to part with Miller.

[mike9289]

Springer and Miller for Max and Lester is approaching fair value without any keeper implications.