AL Trade - Aoki vs. Cruz

[SlideRule]

Pick a side:

Nelson Cruz $16 and Brad Peacock $5
or
Norichika Aoki $17 and Eric Sogard $2

3-yr keeper league, all contracts are new. 10-team, standard roto.

[virgonomic]

Another vote for Cruz.

[Gregg]

Cruz side for me as well.

[chancellor]

Net value, I'd go with the Cruz side, too. But it's a classic "what do you need" deal. 5x5, if you're short of runs and BA and could use some speed, the deal isn't bad. If you need power, clearly the Cruz side is your direction.