Last NL-only keepers

[Trautdiggity]

Need to choose 2 of the following. 10-team NL-only. I've gone back and forth a dozen times on this. We also use k/9 rather than ks. I will have a $5 option on each of them after this season if that impacts.

Shelby Miller $10
Hyun-Jin Ryu $7
Francisco Liriano $1

[Hornsby]

Much as I hate Liriano as a Twins fan, he's a keeper at a buck. And I'd take the upside of Miller for the other keeper.

[whalewang]

Liriano and Miller.

[joncarlos]

I might like Ryu the best of any of them. So I really can't help.

[roadtrip68]

Liriano for this year otherwise ryu.

[Sharky]

Definitely Ryu. Probably Liriano after that because of cost differential.

[whalewang]

The K/9 for each is as follows:
Miller = 8.8
Ryu = 7.2
Liriano = 9.1

Ryu in K/9 leagues is worse than not great, it's a detriment. He will help in Wins, WHiP and ERA though.
Liriano's WHiP is hurtful but he's productive in all the other categories (in that park).
Miller has the most upside and will be helpful in all the categories. Because of this, he is easily the best of the bunch but he carries the highest pricetag. Prices included I'd rank Miller > Liriano > Ryu.

[overkill94]

There's gotta be a way to trade one of those. Liriano is easily the riskiest of the bunch, but at $1 it'd be hard to throw him back. Honestly though, I'd be more comfortable with Ryu and Miller than I would with Liriano.