Trade Question Help...need answers before 9am...keeper deadline

[luckyheel]

AL only 8 team 5x5 league:

I have Felix Hernandez at $28 and an owner is offering me Machado-10 (option to add 1 year for +$5), Oswaldo Arcia-10 and Michael Pineda-7

What do you think??

[joncarlos]

It's close, but in an 8 team league I'd still rather have Felix than a $15 Machado for the next 2 years. But it's close. I think Arcia and Pineda have to be pretty close to (or above) their auction values, no

[luckyheel]

That's what I was thinking...
Thanks, JC

[Hammer]

in an 8 teamer I am all about studs and duds as the replacement level players aren't bad. I hope you didn't make the deal.