Mixed League Keepers

[madducks]

14 team mixed 5x5 w/$300 budget. Positions are: C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF-4, UT-2, SP-5, P-2, RP-2, BENCH-4

Need 8 keepers from the list below. Definitely keeping Goldschmidt, Strasburg, and Holland. Leaning toward keeping Beltre too because i would like a top 3B and i would probably have to spend $40+ at the auction to get one of Beltre/Longoria/Wright and Miggy is being kept. Thanks for any advice offered.

C - Carlos Ruiz $1
1B - Joey Votto $52
2B - José Altuve $6
3B - Adrián Béltre $32
SS - José Reyes $50
OF - Carl Crawford $15
OF - Hunter Pence $23
OF - Alex Gordon $11
C-OF - Evan Gattis $1
OF - George Springer $1
1B - Paul Goldschmidt $11
UT - David Ortiz $16
SP - Stephen Strasburg $11
SP - Homer Bailey $4
SP - Mike Minor $6
SP - Andy Pettitte $1
SP - Dan Haren $17
SP - Danny Salazar $1
SP-RP - Joe Kelly $1
RP - Greg Holland $8
RP - Grant Balfour $12
RP - Edward Mujica $1

[Andrewski]

OBP or Average? I'm assuming OBP...

3B - Adrián Béltre $32
OF - Alex Gordon $11
1B - Paul Goldschmidt $11
UT - David Ortiz $16
SP - Stephen Strasburg $11
SP - Homer Bailey $4
SP - Mike Minor $6
SP - Danny Salazar $1
RP - Greg Holland $8

And the last one would come down between C-OF - Evan Gattis $1 and OF - George Springer $1, depending on your rules on minor leaguers.

[madducks]

OBP or Average? I'm assuming OBP...

3B - Adrián Béltre $32
OF - Alex Gordon $11
1B - Paul Goldschmidt $11
UT - David Ortiz $16
SP - Stephen Strasburg $11
SP - Homer Bailey $4
SP - Mike Minor $6
SP - Danny Salazar $1
RP - Greg Holland $8

And the last one would come down between C-OF - Evan Gattis $1 and OF - George Springer $1, depending on your rules on minor leaguers.

Sorry, it's batting average. Minor leaguers are on the active roster which includes 4 bench spots. And i can only keep 8.

[joncarlos]

1B - Paul Goldschmidt $11
UT - David Ortiz $16
SP - Stephen Strasburg $11
SP - Homer Bailey $4
SP - Mike Minor $6
RP - Greg Holland $8

That's 6. I would lean towards adding Pence and Salazar. If you think OF is deep and 3B is shallow, I wouldn't argue with Beltre over Pence. Tough to leave off Altuve but with no MI, I think you can get a usable 2B for a buck at the end. I wouldn't argue dropping Salazar and keeping 2 of Beltre/Pence/Altuve but I know Salazar has all of the helium right now.

[TyWebb004]

Goldy
Beltre
Gordon
Ortiz
Strasburg
Bailey
Salazar
Holland

[Mithrandir]

14 team mixed 5x5 w/$300 budget. Positions are: C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF-4, UT-2, SP-5, P-2, RP-2, BENCH-4

Need 8 keepers from the list below. Definitely keeping Goldschmidt, Strasburg, and Holland. Leaning toward keeping Beltre too because i would like a top 3B and i would probably have to spend $40+ at the auction to get one of Beltre/Longoria/Wright and Miggy is being kept. Thanks for any advice offered.

C - Carlos Ruiz $1
1B - Joey Votto $52
2B - José Altuve $6
3B - Adrián Béltre $32
SS - José Reyes $50
OF - Carl Crawford $15
OF - Hunter Pence $23
OF - Alex Gordon $11
C-OF - Evan Gattis $1
OF - George Springer $1
1B - Paul Goldschmidt $11
UT - David Ortiz $16
SP - Stephen Strasburg $11
SP - Homer Bailey $4
SP - Mike Minor $6
SP - Andy Pettitte $1
SP - Dan Haren $17
SP - Danny Salazar $1
SP-RP - Joe Kelly $1
RP - Greg Holland $8
RP - Grant Balfour $12
RP - Edward Mujica $1

Springer is the only iffy one. Since we added an extra bench spot you may choose to keep him at that bench spot until he gets called up. I could see keeping Gordon instead of him. Or even Minor.

[DJBeasties]

14 team mixed 5x5 w/$300 budget. Positions are: C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF-4, UT-2, SP-5, P-2, RP-2, BENCH-4

Need 8 keepers from the list below. Definitely keeping Goldschmidt, Strasburg, and Holland. Leaning toward keeping Beltre too because i would like a top 3B and i would probably have to spend $40+ at the auction to get one of Beltre/Longoria/Wright and Miggy is being kept. Thanks for any advice offered.

C - Carlos Ruiz $1
1B - Joey Votto $52
2B - José Altuve $6
3B - Adrián Béltre $32
SS - José Reyes $50
OF - Carl Crawford $15
OF - Hunter Pence $23
OF - Alex Gordon $11
C-OF - Evan Gattis $1
OF - George Springer $1
1B - Paul Goldschmidt $11
UT - David Ortiz $16
SP - Stephen Strasburg $11
SP - Homer Bailey $4
SP - Mike Minor $6
SP - Andy Pettitte $1
SP - Dan Haren $17
SP - Danny Salazar $1
SP-RP - Joe Kelly $1
RP - Greg Holland $8
RP - Grant Balfour $12
RP - Edward Mujica $1

Holland
Goldschmidt
Salazar
Strasburg
Bailey
Beltre
Ortiz
Gordon

[Andrewski]

Sorry, it's batting average. Minor leaguers are on the active roster which includes 4 bench spots. And i can only keep 8.

I am still learning to count.

3B - Adrián Béltre $32
1B - Paul Goldschmidt $11
UT - David Ortiz $16
SP - Stephen Strasburg $11
SP - Homer Bailey $4
SP - Mike Minor $6
SP - Danny Salazar $1
RP - Greg Holland $8

[madducks]

So, it looks like everyone is in agreement on:
1B - Paul Goldschmidt $11
3B - Adrián Béltre $32
UT - David Ortiz $16
SP - Stephen Strasburg $11
SP - Homer Bailey $4
SP - Danny Salazar $1
RP - Greg Holland $8

and split evenly on:
OF - Alex Gordon $11
SP - Mike Minor $6

These top seven were actually on my original list along with Springer. Then i started second guessing the Ortiz at age 38 pick. But, i guess $16 isn't too much risk.

Anyone else besides Mith think that a $1 Springer could produce a great return? I'm thinking that he will easily sell for $10+ at our auction and could even out-produce Gordon in the second half. Since they have similar skill sets, perhaps their remaining eligibility should be considered. Springer could be kept two more years at $5 increases per year. This would be the last year that Gordon could be kept. Thoughts?