Help with finetuning my NL 5x5 keepers

[Falcon]

Looking for a little help/advice. Have to choose 10 keepers from the following in my 10-team, 5x5, NL-only, straight-draft (no $$) league:

No-brainers
Stanton
Holliday
A. Gon
Heyward
Hamels
Kimbrel

Need four from the following:
Headley
Revere
B.J. Upton
Cashner
Cingrani
Cueto

Thoughts?

[Hammer]

Headley
Revere
Cingrani
Cueto

[joncarlos]

I'd take the 3 pitchers and whichever of Revere/Headley is limping less. Headley looks like he'll start the year on the DL. Not sure how Revere is doing.

[Sharky]

I'd take the 3 pitchers and whichever of Revere/Headley is limping less. Headley looks like he'll start the year on the DL. Not sure how Revere is doing.

I probably lean this way too. Cashner could be quite good.

[Gregg]

Depending on the rules, I would only keep the 3 pitchers.

[Don Quixote]

Headley
Revere
Cingrani
Cueto

Keep in mind that Hammer is the biggest Reds supporter on the board.

I say Revere, Cashner, Cingrani, and flip a coin Headley vs. Cueto. Avoid Upton at all costs.