AL only trade offer

[price]

12 team AL only keeper 5x5 $260 roto

My $23 Kuroda 2014 and Buerhle $9 2014
for
Y.Gomes $4 2015 ( I have no catchers) and Jarred Cosart $2 2015

Trying to rebuilt a bit after last year and I have the following starting pitchers as possibles to take into the draft.

Kazmir $10
A.Sanchez $32
F.Hernandez $38
Santiago $1
Smyly $8
H.Ramirez $12
D.Salazar $13
Kuroda $23
Buerhle $9

Cosart was a top prospect

Pretty fair deal?

Thanks

P.S. also looking at a possible F.Hernandez for N.Castellanos $2 2016 and C.Lewis $3 2015 (may take Hollands spot)

[Hornsby]

1 or 2 catcher league?

And Cosart had terrible control issues, as well as an abysmal K rate last season. With all of Houston's young arms on the horizon, I wouldn't count on him holding a job for too long, unless he can somehow discover where the plate is.

[Moonlight J]

Love Gomes...I do this deal.

[chancellor]

Love Gomes...I do this deal.

I'd do this deal to get Yan alone. Cozart is at value IMO

[joncarlos]

I'd do this deal to get Yan alone. Cozart is at value IMO

Agree with this. In a 12 team AL league you have to keep Cosart but he's not terribly exciting.

[TranaGreg]

1 or 2 catcher league?

this is the deciding factor. 1, I say no. 2, yes.

[SlideRule]

It's an interesting one, but yeah I tend to agree that the $4 Gomes is the best part here and you go that direction, esp if it's a 2 catcher league.

[YourPalChrisMal]

12 team AL only keeper 5x5 $260 roto

My $23 Kuroda 2014 and Buerhle $9 2014
for
Y.Gomes $4 2015 ( I have no catchers) and Jarred Cosart $2 2015

Trying to rebuilt a bit after last year and I have the following starting pitchers as possibles to take into the draft.

Kazmir $10
A.Sanchez $32
F.Hernandez $38
Santiago $1
Smyly $8
H.Ramirez $12
D.Salazar $13
Kuroda $23
Buerhle $9

Cosart was a top prospect

Pretty fair deal?

Thanks

P.S. also looking at a possible F.Hernandez for N.Castellanos $2 2016 and C.Lewis $3 2015 (may take Hollands spot)

Why would the other guy make that trade? Isn't Kuroda close to fully priced, and does Buerhle even go for $9 if back in the draft? I have Buerhle for $5 in my AL-only 4x4 league and I am probably going to toss him back.

[cool hand]

I agree with the above. Gomes is the only part of the deal that appears to be of any value; i.e,. go ahead and make the swap.

The more interesting question, to me, is the Fernandez for Castellanos/Lewis offer. I think I would make that swap, and decide on Lewis as ST wears on and reveals more information.

[axman]

I would take both deals for Gomes and Castellanos. At the deadline decide on Lewis and Cosart.

[BuckyBuckner]

Make both deals and see if you can get someone better for Lewis and Cosart in a third deal.

[price]

1 or 2 catcher league?

And Cosart had terrible control issues, as well as an abysmal K rate last season. With all of Houston's young arms on the horizon, I wouldn't count on him holding a job for too long, unless he can somehow discover where the plate is.

Yes it is a 2 catcher league

[price]

I could also look at getting a $1 Shuck 2015 or $1 Tanner Scheppers (save potential?) 2015 instead of Cozart? Are any of the other 2 any better?

Thanks a ton guys!

[Don Quixote]

I could also look at getting a $1 Shuck 2015 or $1 Tanner Scheppers (save potential?) 2015 instead of Cozart? Are any of the other 2 any better?

Thanks a ton guys!

I'm not crazy about Shuck, but Scheppers looks to be an above average middle reliever/setup guy even if he doesn't get a shot at closing.