Keeper help.

[onejayhawk]

16 teams, ROTO H2H, picking last each round.
I ran these out back in October, but the results were mixed and things have changed with a couple players.

Core group:

Paul Goldschmidt 1B
Robinson Canó 2B
Adrián Béltre 3B
Jean Segura SS
Christian Yelich OF
Andrew McCutchen OF

I need 8 of these. Each will have options for 1 or 2 additional years. I highlighted a couple of no brainers. Harvey would likely get 2 option years. Option is draft slot minus 4 rounds, so rounds 13-17 get two option years. SP is harder to draft than RP.

Brad Miller 2B/SS
Josh Rutledge 2B/SS
Lonnie Chisenhall 3B
Matt Davidson 3B
Yasmani Grandal C
Yan Gomes C/1B
Kole Calhoun OF
Leonys Martín OF
Jayson Werth OF
Josh Willingham OF
Tanner Roark RP
Pedro Strop RP
Tyler Thornburg RP
José Fernández SP
Matt Harvey SP
Zach McAllister SP
Yusmeiro Petit SP/RP
Zack Wheeler SP
Francisco Lindor SS

J

[joncarlos]

I think I agree with ElD though I might like Martin more than Calhoun. Maybe in a league that deep where SP is hard to find, McAllister warrants consideration over an outfielder?

[onejayhawk]

Calhoun vs Martin is a question, since keeping both is unlikely. Reputation aside, they are less than 6 month difference in age--late 87 and early 88. Calhoun hits for better power, walks more and strikes out less, yet most people prefer Martin as a first response. I will not have the luxury of watching camp.

I may look at McAllister, but Lindor is also tempting. Cleveland has been shopping Asdrubel Cabrera.

J

[Moonlight J]

Martin over Calhoun all day long. Martin is a special talent

[onejayhawk]

I am leaning to eldiablo's six

Name Y! (rnd)
werth 112 (10)
Martin 148 (11)
Miller 213 (13)
Calhoun 243 (14)
harvey 287 (15)
davidson 1065 (17)

My question is Calhoun, Strop or McAlister? Both Strop and McAlister will bump the option cost of Harvey a round. Or should I take none and draft in the 17th, which is a nice round to take a AA prospect (3 year option). I could also decline Wheeler's 12th round option. The others move up and I pick in the 17th.

Twisting things even further, because of their Y! rank, if I keep Calhoun and Rutledge (instead of Davidson), I push Harvey back 2 rounds and get an extra option year. Is that worth it?

J