Castro, Arenado for Kimbrel?

[Falcon]

Looking toward next year in my 10-team, NL-only, 5x5, keeper league.

Have been offered S. Castro and N. Arenado for Kimbrel.

Can keep 10. Current keepers are Stanton, Holiday, Headley, Sandoval, Carpenter, Revere, Hamels, Zimmerman and Kimbrel. Also have Wood, Weeks, Montero in possible mix, depending on second half.

Thoughts on this deal?

[Gregg]

I hate this deal for you.

For what it is worth, I am a Cubs fan and thought they should have traded Castro before the season started.

[cavebird]

It sounds like there are no salaries involved. If that is the case, I think Kimbrel is a far better option for next year. I look for a bounce back to some extent from Castro, but Kimbrel's numbers are hard to replicate. I would think you could get more.

[chancellor]

I agree with CB, not only because you can get more, but your keeper list would have three 3Bmen on it.

[cavebird]

I agree with CB, not only because you can get more, but your keeper list would have three 3Bmen on it.

Four depending on which Zimmerman(n).

[chancellor]

Four depending on which Zimmerman(n).

True - I figured Jordan since he was listed with the pitchers. But the point's good, if it is Ryan, I wouldn't even consider the deal.