McCutchen or Goldschmidt

[saul]

5X5 keeper league.
Have Votto at 1B & can move Headley from UT to CI.
Is trading Goldschmidt for McCutchen a no brainer.
In 3rd in sb's & close to top in power numbers.

[joncarlos]

Wow, that's a really tough call. What's their keeper status?

I would guess most people like Goldy better. He does steal a few bags. He has a ton of power. He's in a great park. He's probably a first round pick next year. He could finish close to .305-40-15sb.

Cutch looks like the 31HR/.327 season he put up last year was a little flukey. But the Pirates are running a lot more this year. He could easily finish as a .290-20-90-110r-40sb guy.

If there was any way that Cutch was a better keeper due to cheaper price or extra years then I might take him.

[saul]

No prices, roto snake draft

[onejayhawk]

I would see if Votto would bring more than Goldschmidt.

J

[overkill94]

I still like Cutch a bit better, but it's close. If you need the SBs then I'd definitely go for it.