Granderson trade value

[swampdragon]

I have been offered Justin Upton for Granderson in a yahoo 12 team. The idea is that Granderson would be an potential 10th round keeper for him next year and he is packing it in.

Upton has slowed down but I am guessing is very streaky and will turn it around.

He also has Adam Jones.

What is the likely difference between Granderson and Upton - ROS
and also Granderson and Adam Jones - ROS?

Thanks

[onejayhawk]

I just picked up Granderson, reluctantly, in a dump trade.

J

[swampdragon]

I just picked up Granderson, reluctantly, in a dump trade.

J

What did you trade away?

[joncarlos]

I like Jones more than either of them, probably by a lot. But I do think I'd take J-Up over Grandy by a small margin.

[revo]

I'd do it.

We need more specifics about the # of keepers, because Grandy as a 10th rounder seems about right these days, especially if there's no many keepers diluting the top 100.

[swampdragon]

thanks for input - keepers is only 3 per team (no one in first three rounds) - they just move up one round for 2 more years

what are projections for the three of them - ROS

[swampdragon]

I might ask if Revere and Granderson would get me
Upton and Bourne - that seems more like a dump trade.

I dont think that there will be that big a diffference between grandy and upton once it is over.

[onejayhawk]

What did you trade away?

Granderson and K Johnson(+2years) for Sano(+3) and Arcia(+4)

My OF has been a disaster.

J