One, the Other, or None?

[DJBeasties]

Local league, 12 teams, points-league:


Encarnacion just picked up 3B-eligibility and I am getting peppered with offers on him.


Here is my current team:


C - Napoli
1B - Goldschmidt
2B - D. Murphy
3B - Longoria
SS - Prado
OF - Holliday
OF - Cuddyer
OF - Cain
UTIL - Encarnacion



Offers:

Offer #1: Braun, Kinsler, Profar ($3 next year) for Encarnacion, Holliday

Offer #2: Cespedes, Butler for Encarnacion



Do you like any of these enough? Or just stay put?

[joncarlos]

Kinsler/Braun is probably not quite as good as E5/Holliday but you could replace Murphy with a better bat and that might make it better. I love Profar and I'd do it. Even if you don't keep him you can probably flip him for a CarGo style bat down the road.

[DJBeasties]

Thanks JC. I passed on both. I don't like the Kinsler/Braun injuries/nagging injuries/PED stuff enough to flip those two just to get my hands on Profar. I'm in 1st in this league and it's just not enough to me.