Value Rankings for Various Players

[Bodhizefa]

Who is more valuable (rank them for Rest of Year and also for Dynasty League purposes):

1. Goldschmidt or Strasburg
2. James Shields or Wilin Rosario
3. Nolan Arenado or Kyle Seager or Anthony Rendon

[revo]

Rest of year rankings:
1. I'd take Goldschmidt by a smidge
2. This one is close, but give me Big Game James
3. Seager

[Sour Masher]

1. Goldschmidt
2. James Shields
3. Nolan Arenado

[Mithrandir]

1. Goldschmidt
2. James Shields
3. Nolan Arenado

Agreed.

[chancellor]

Going against the grain so far, I love Paul Goldschmidt, but I'd still take Strasburg in a Dynasty league. I'd need a gaping hole and desperate need at 1B to even consider dealing Stras for Goldschmidt straight up.

Shields both for this year and in Dynasty.

Tough call between Seager and Arenado, IMO. But in my case, when in doubt, take the Colorado hitter, so I'd go with Arenado.