Scutaro, Murphy, or Segura?

[red]

5x5 12 team mixed, non-keeper.

How would you rank Scutaro, Segura, and Murphy for a MI slot?

[cavebird]

All of them above the garbage I have?

[B-Fly]

I think they're all in pretty much the same tier for MI, so it depends what you need. Scutaro is probably best for HR, Murphy for AVG, Segura for SBs.

[onejayhawk]

I would roll the dice on the kid. He's off to a hot start.

j

[Sour Masher]

I would roll the dice on the kid. He's off to a hot start.

j

Me too. I like murphy a lot too. Scutaro would be 3rd for me, mostly because of age/injury concerns. 37 year olds scare me, mostly because I'm one and I know how I feel.

[onejayhawk]

Me too. I like murphy a lot too. Scutaro would be 3rd for me, mostly because of age/injury concerns. 37 year olds scare me, mostly because I'm one and I know how I feel.

You kids.

J

[Stephen]

Segura or Scutaro for me.

[onejayhawk]

bump

J

[bryanbutler]

segura > scutaro > murphy

[red]

I went with Segura, although Scutaro has been en fuego recently -- 32 for his last 61!

[Hornsby]

Yeah, Segura by a mile over this group...speed doesn't fade, no matter what. And the power is legit as well.