Bruce or Ubaldo

[ajwseven]

I'm in a 12 team 5x5 H2h league w/ 5 keepers. I've got votto, ubaldo, tulo, longo and mccutchen. I won last year so I have the last pick. I was offered the 6th overall pick and jay bruce for ubaldo and my 1st the 12th overall. If i make the move, the best pitchers left would be jered weaver, hanson and liriano. Should I go for it? if so, do i target one of those three or continue with my hitting? all comments are appreciated.
-ajwseven

[joncarlos]

What hitters are available?

Assuming you can get Hansen or Weaver, I like Bruce and one of them better than Ubaldo and whatever hitter is likely going to be available.

[Hammer]

I agree with JC

[The Dane]

I also agree. Take the hitter. In a 12-team mixed, pitching will be plentiful, probably not to the level of Ubaldo, but a replacement will be considerably better than a Bruce replacement.

[willthethrill]

Make the deal.

[ajwseven]

If I can't get hanson or weaver and the choices are liriano, cain or oswalt should i still make the move? If so, how do you rank those three?