AL prospects trade - Montero or Cain?

[SlideRule]

Doing the reserve draft for my AL only and I took Lorenzo Cain. Other owner that took Jesus Montero (first) is interested in trading the two. We can keep them up to three years, both are at a fixed salary of $8.

Should I do it? Montero is the more touted prospect but Cain seems more likely to contribute this year. Thx.

[SlideRule]

No thoughts? Will need to make a decision on this soon. I know some folks out there know more about Montero's fantasy outlook than I do.

[virgonomic]

Stick with Cain. You may be able to get Montero + for him in a month.

[chancellor]

You'll get more out of Cain this year, but I'd like Montero long term.

[schlesinj]

You'll get more out of Cain this year, but I'd like Montero long term.

Agreed. That said, if this is a keeper league then Montero has more of a name value and you maybe able to flip him for a stud at dump time.