Mixed league keepeer suggestions?

[MagSeven]

12 team 5x5, $260 cap, can keep 8. Mith & Madducks are in the same league.

C - Salvador Perez $1
C - Alex Avila $6 *
1B - Ike Davis $7 *
2B - Rickie Weeks $16
3B - Mike Moustakas $6 *
2B-3B-SS-OF - Martin Prado $7
SS - J.J. Hardy $10
OF - Josh Reddick $1
1B-OF - Carlos Lee $9
OF - Jason Kubel $12
OF - Anthony Gose $1
1B-OF - Brandon Belt $3
1B-3B - Mike Olt $1
OF - Cameron Maybin $6 *
1B - Matt Adams $1
SP-RP - Lance Lynn $1
SP - Edwin Jackson $5
SP - Trevor Bauer $1
SP - Yovani Gallardo $35
SP - Trevor Cahill $5
RP - Carlos Marmol $8
RP - Jonathan Broxton $7
RP - Tom Wilhelmsen $1
SP - Jaime Garcia $18
SP - Daniel Hudson $11 * *

Any early thoughts would be greatly appreciated!!! Thanks!

[joncarlos]

The only guys I love are Prado, Perez and Lynn. After that you have a ton of low AVG guys (Moose, Ike, Reddick, Avila, Maybin, Hardy), some cheap closers and a couple of at-value starters in Cahill and EJax (and maybe Bauer?).

What does your league typically value the most? My list of 5 would probably be Wilhelmsen, Moose, Ike, Cahill and Reddick

[Erik]

12 team 5x5, $260 cap, can keep 8. Mith & Madducks are in the same league.

C - Salvador Perez $1
C - Alex Avila $6 *
1B - Ike Davis $7 *
2B - Rickie Weeks $16
3B - Mike Moustakas $6 *
2B-3B-SS-OF - Martin Prado $7
SS - J.J. Hardy $10
OF - Josh Reddick $1
1B-OF - Carlos Lee $9
OF - Jason Kubel $12
OF - Anthony Gose $1
1B-OF - Brandon Belt $3
1B-3B - Mike Olt $1
OF - Cameron Maybin $6 *
1B - Matt Adams $1
SP-RP - Lance Lynn $1
SP - Edwin Jackson $5
SP - Trevor Bauer $1
SP - Yovani Gallardo $35
SP - Trevor Cahill $5
RP - Carlos Marmol $8
RP - Jonathan Broxton $7
RP - Tom Wilhelmsen $1
SP - Jaime Garcia $18
SP - Daniel Hudson $11 * *

Any early thoughts would be greatly appreciated!!! Thanks!

My suggestions in bold.

[BigJonEmpire]

C - Salvador Perez $1
C - Alex Avila $6 *
1B - Ike Davis $7 *
2B - Rickie Weeks $16
3B - Mike Moustakas $6 *
2B-3B-SS-OF - Martin Prado $7
SS - J.J. Hardy $10
OF - Josh Reddick $1
1B-OF - Carlos Lee $9
OF - Jason Kubel $12
OF - Anthony Gose $1
1B-OF - Brandon Belt $3
1B-3B - Mike Olt $1
OF - Cameron Maybin $6 *
1B - Matt Adams $1
SP-RP - Lance Lynn $1
SP - Edwin Jackson $5
SP - Trevor Bauer $1
SP - Yovani Gallardo $35
SP - Trevor Cahill $5
RP - Carlos Marmol $8
RP - Jonathan Broxton $7
RP - Tom Wilhelmsen $1
SP - Jaime Garcia $18
SP - Daniel Hudson $11 * *

[Silentmist]

C - Salvador Perez $1
C - Alex Avila $6 *
1B - Ike Davis $7 *
2B - Rickie Weeks $16
3B - Mike Moustakas $6 *
2B-3B-SS-OF - Martin Prado $7
SS - J.J. Hardy $10
OF - Josh Reddick $1
1B-OF - Carlos Lee $9
OF - Jason Kubel $12
OF - Anthony Gose $1
1B-OF - Brandon Belt $3
1B-3B - Mike Olt $1
OF - Cameron Maybin $6 *
1B - Matt Adams $1
SP-RP - Lance Lynn $1
SP - Edwin Jackson $5
SP - Trevor Bauer $1
SP - Yovani Gallardo $35
SP - Trevor Cahill $5
RP - Carlos Marmol $8
RP - Jonathan Broxton $7
RP - Tom Wilhelmsen $1
SP - Jaime Garcia $18
SP - Daniel Hudson $11 * *

[Mithrandir]

C - Salvador Perez $1
C - Alex Avila $6 *
1B - Ike Davis $7 *
2B - Rickie Weeks $16
3B - Mike Moustakas $6 *
2B-3B-SS-OF - Martin Prado $7
SS - J.J. Hardy $10
OF - Josh Reddick $1
1B-OF - Carlos Lee $9
OF - Jason Kubel $12
OF - Anthony Gose $1
1B-OF - Brandon Belt $3
1B-3B - Mike Olt $1
OF - Cameron Maybin $6 *
1B - Matt Adams $1
SP-RP - Lance Lynn $1
SP - Edwin Jackson $5
SP - Trevor Bauer $1
SP - Yovani Gallardo $35
SP - Trevor Cahill $5
RP - Carlos Marmol $8
RP - Jonathan Broxton $7
RP - Tom Wilhelmsen $1
SP - Jaime Garcia $18
SP - Daniel Hudson $11 * *

I agree with these 8.

[madducks]

C - Salvador Perez $1
1B - Ike Davis $7 *
3B - Mike Moustakas $6 *
2B-3B-SS-OF - Martin Prado $7
OF - Cameron Maybin $6 *
SP-RP - Lance Lynn $1
RP - Tom Wilhelmsen $1
RP - Jonathan Broxton $7 (assuming he is the closer)

[dannahann]

C - Salvador Perez $1
C - Alex Avila $6 *
1B - Ike Davis $7 *
2B - Rickie Weeks $16
3B - Mike Moustakas $6 *
2B-3B-SS-OF - Martin Prado $7
SS - J.J. Hardy $10
OF - Josh Reddick $1
1B-OF - Carlos Lee $9
OF - Jason Kubel $12
OF - Anthony Gose $1
1B-OF - Brandon Belt $3
1B-3B - Mike Olt $1
OF - Cameron Maybin $6 *
1B - Matt Adams $1
SP-RP - Lance Lynn $1
SP - Edwin Jackson $5
SP - Trevor Bauer $1
SP - Yovani Gallardo $35
SP - Trevor Cahill $5
RP - Carlos Marmol $8
RP - Jonathan Broxton $7
RP - Tom Wilhelmsen $1
SP - Jaime Garcia $18
SP - Daniel Hudson $11 * *

[DJBeasties]

What are the asterisks?

[Mithrandir]

What are the asterisks?

They indicate number of years kept. More for internal use by Commish to keep track of which players are still keepable and which players get thrown back into the draft as players can only be kept for 3 years.

[DJBeasties]

Thanks Mith!

Ok here are my picks:

C - Salvador Perez $1
C - Alex Avila $6 *
1B - Ike Davis $7 *
2B - Rickie Weeks $16
3B - Mike Moustakas $6 *
2B-3B-SS-OF - Martin Prado $7
SS - J.J. Hardy $10
OF - Josh Reddick $1
1B-OF - Carlos Lee $9
OF - Jason Kubel $12
OF - Anthony Gose $1
1B-OF - Brandon Belt $3
1B-3B - Mike Olt $1
OF - Cameron Maybin $6 *
1B - Matt Adams $1
SP-RP - Lance Lynn $1
SP - Edwin Jackson $5
SP - Trevor Bauer $1
SP - Yovani Gallardo $35
SP - Trevor Cahill $5
RP - Carlos Marmol $8
RP - Jonathan Broxton $7
RP - Tom Wilhelmsen $1
SP - Jaime Garcia $18
SP - Daniel Hudson $11 * *

[MagSeven]

Thanks guys! I figured there would be a variety of answers!