quick closer question: NL-only

[scottw]

I am working a large-scale trade He made the offer either / or: AJ Puk or Evan Phillips. The rest of the trade is the same; salaries: Puk is $9-1, Phillips is $5-2.
Which would you go for? Speed is of the essence, as we are both working on trades with others.
As always, thanks in advance!
Scottw

[Sharky]

Phillips. Better team, better health.

[Ken]

I'd go Phillips.

[scottw]

I think I agree on Phillips, too. The only question I have involves their competition for saves. Graterol seems more formidable than Floro or T Scott. What is your thinking on this?
Thanks!

[scottw]

While I do worry about Graterol, I did the deal for Phillips. Thanks Ken and Sharkey!