12 team mixed 5x5: final keeper due tonight

[amcg]

Howdy folks. Final (8th) keeper in a 12 team mixed 5x5 keeper league. No contracts. Who's your pick from the following five?

• Tristan McKenzie
• Jake McCarthy
• Steven Kwan
• Seiya Suzuki
• Nick Castellanos

What say you?

[Ken]

Tristan

[The Feral Slasher]

Howdy folks. Final (8th) keeper in a 12 team mixed 5x5 keeper league. No contracts. Who's your pick from the following five?

• Tristan McKenzie
• Jake McCarthy
• Steven Kwan
• Seiya Suzuki
• Nick Castellanos

What say you?

That is a very difficult question, auction calculator has them all pretty close in value. if Suzuki was not hurt i would probably go with him....but I'd pick McKenzie or McCarthy based on if I needed pitching or hitting more. I'd lean a bit towards McCarthy I think.

[virgonomic]

Another vote for Tristan but McCarthy is fair if you have lots of pitching already.

[amcg]

My first seven keepers:

• Gerrit Cole
• Jose Ramirez
• Marcus Semien
• Matt Olson
• Xander Bogaerts
• Jose Altuve
• Tommy Edman

[harmon]

Easily Tristan given your other keepers.

[The Feral Slasher]

My first seven keepers:

• Gerrit Cole
• Jose Ramirez
• Marcus Semien
• Matt Olson
• Xander Bogaerts
• Jose Altuve
• Tommy Edman

probably keep Triston...but see if you can trade any of them since they are close in value. Good Luck !

[Ken]

I dont think I'd want to start McCarthy in a 12 team mixed. There's some 4th OFer profile/risk there and they have a lot of OFers. He may prove me wrong and steal some bases, but there's some risk to consider that I wouldn't want as a keeper in a 12.

[madducks]

McKenzie = future ace.