Who do you like better?

[Gregg]

Holland for $10 or Raburn for $7?

[joncarlos]

I think I'd take Holland. Though I am not sure I'd keep either.

[Hammer]

agree with JC.

[Lucky]

Holland for $10 or Raburn for $7?

Are we talking about Derek Holland here?

I'm thinking Holland will have a 4.00+ ERA and a Whip over 1.30.

Raburn, by contrast, could easily be a 25 home run hitter with an average that won't kill you. I think Raburn is a keeper at $7 in an AL or a mixed league.

[price]

Holland for $10 or Raburn for $7?

Raburn especially in an AL only

[Flyman]

Raburn and not even close, IMHO.

[Gregg]

I should have specified AL only.

Thanks for the replies.

[schlesinj]

I will join in on Raburn.

[price]

My thing is if it is close choosing between a hitter and pitcher, I always go with the hitter. If Holland was $1-2, then I'd have to consider him.