Trade Hosmer for Fister?

[price]

12 team AL only 5x5 w/obp roto keeper w/cap (currently in 2nd 2 points back)

Could use some pitching help. Rotation: CJ, Shields, Kuroda, Holland, A.J. Griffin, Garcia and Pettitte DL (4th in wins 7 from top and 5th place is one behind me, 3rd in K's 20 behind 2nd and 82 behind first, but slowly gaining. Could also pick up 2-4 spots in e.r.a./whip or go the other way)

My Hosmer $10 2013 and Dirks $2 2013 for Fister $12 2014 and Luke Scott $14 2014 or C.Davis $9 2014

Morrow for $14 2013 may also be an option, but may cost a little more

Yes or no

Thanks

[revo]

I have to believe this is just a sophomore slump for Hosmer, and last year was an anomaly for Fister. Chris Davis doesn't help in OBP, and Scott isn't enough. Pass.

[wannabegriffey]

I have to believe this is just a sophomore slump for Hosmer, and last year was an anomaly for Fister. Chris Davis doesn't help in OBP, and Scott isn't enough. Pass.

Fister is a damn fine pitcher and too many people discount his contribution.

[revo]

Fister is a damn fine pitcher and too many people discount his contribution.

2009: 103 ERA+
2010: 96 ERA+
2011: 138 ERA+
2012: 103 ERA+

he has a great K/BB ratio, but not because he strikes a lot of guys out.

He's solid enough, but I wouldn't trade a potential stud bat for him.

[price]

2009: 103 ERA+
2010: 96 ERA+
2011: 138 ERA+
2012: 103 ERA+

he has a great K/BB ratio, but not because he strikes a lot of guys out.

He's solid enough, but I wouldn't trade a potential stud bat for him.

I told the other owner no on the offer and might counter him.

i am trying to get Cespedes for him from another owner. Cespedes could be an ok keeper at $23 for next 2 years if he keeps up. hosmer is cheaper for next year, but I need production this season. I'm asking for Cespedes and Masterson or Liriano from him. I have enough to play the match ups for either one.