Jose Reyes for Jordan Zimmerman

[Clams]

NL only, 10 teams, standard 5x5. Assume one team needs an SP and the other is looking for steals and offense (duh!). Is this a fair deal or is one side getting the better of the other?

FWIW, I'm having a hard time deciding who's getting the better end, which usually tells me that it's fair (or close to it)

Thanks.

[joncarlos]

I don't know either. I would probably take Zimm in a vacuum. Says the man who took Reyes with a first round pick.

[Sam]

Without knowing the rest of the teams, it seems pretty fair. One owner is getting the pitching he needs and the other owner is getting the steals and offense he needs.

[Sharky]

Reyes is probably the better end of the deal. Both are good, and it's probably not "unfair." But Reyes offers the more scarce commodity (SB and position).