Hosmer or Harper

[Sam]

Who would you rather have for the next two years - Hosmer or Harper? Both have identical contracts ($5 this year and next, $10 the following then back in the auction pool). Standard 5 categories + OPS.

I'd assume Hosmer is the better bet for this year because Harper will likely end up back in the minors once the team gets healthy but how close is it for the next two years between the two?

[rotogod]

AND I love Harper.. But think Bryce will be better long-term, Hosmer short-term.

[Sour Masher]

AND I love Harper.. But think Bryce will be better long-term, Hosmer short-term.

I agree. Next 5 years, Harper, but two, Hosmer--Harper will no doubt go on some power tears, but he'll still have growing pains over the next two years.

[joncarlos]

Yeah, Hosmer should finish way, way ahead.