Trade R Zimmerman for Tommy Hanson

[hotcorner13]

CBS 10-team H2H Points league. I’ve been offered Tommy Hanson for Ryan Zimmerman or Justin Upton. I have depth at both positions, so I can afford to trade one, I just don’t know if it’s enough in return. He also has Greinke, Minor, Shields, Verlander and Garza. Verlander and Shields are too much to ask for unless I sweeten the pot a little. Is Hanson a fair trade for Zimmerman or should I target one of the others? Here’s my roster:

C McCann
1B Teixiera
2B Espinosa
SS Andrus
3B B Lawrie
OF J Upton
OF Bautista
OF Stanton
UT Ad Jones
BN Zimmerman

SP Bumgarner
SP Beachy
SP Buehrle
SP Norris
SP A Sanchez
RP J Johnson
RP Sale
BN Lincecum
BN Leubke
BN McCarthy
BN Marshall

[Gregg]

Given your team I would make the trade.

Zimm has missed three games already this year. Nice player but I just don't trust him.

[Sam]

Given your team I would make the trade.

Zimm has missed three games already this year. Nice player but I just don't trust him.

Agreed - I think you have the depth to make the trade so it'd be in your favor. However, you have alot of pitching- do you really need to be adding to it? What about trading a SP+position player to upgrade somewhere else?

[revo]

I wouldn't hesitate for a second in passing on this deal.

Hanson is still an injury risk, and in this shallow a league, starting pitching is dime-a-dozen. To note, you have Tim Lincecum, Cory Leubke and Sean Marshall on your bench, so why even bother with Hanson. 100% pass.

[Riff Raff]

Hanson is still an injury risk,

So is Zimmerman ...

[Judge Jude]

Zimmerman to the DL today.
no risk - now a certainty.

[Gregg]

Missed it by...this much.