Bautista/Bum/Ethier/Montero for Felix/Santana/Cepedes/Ichiro

[CMGee]

Standard 5x5 mixed league. Huge deal offered, which includes an extra first and second round pick next year for my 3rd and 4th rounders.

Deal would be giving up: Bautista/Montero/Ethier and Bumgarner for Felix/Carlos Santana/Cespedes and Ichiro.


Current Lineup:
C: M. Montero
1b: Gonzalez
2b: Espinoza
SS: Reyes
3b: Bautista
OF: Bourn
OF: Werth
OF: Ethier
Util: Headley/Gordon

SP: Hamels, Bumgarner, Morrow, Billingsley, Santana, Cahill, Masterson
RP: League, Casilla

Other than the fact that this doesn't address a glaring need that I have at Closer -- any thoughts? I'd love to have Felix, but think this might be overpaying.

Thanks all.

C

[swampdragon]

nope - dont give up on Bautista

not even that close.

[chancellor]

I agree with both elD and swampdragon - bad deal for you. Pass. I don't even see a worthwhile counter.

[Sour Masher]

I agree with everyone else for this year. Some of the long term evaluation depends on what sort of players come with those picks. I don't know how many keepers there are, so I didn't really consider the picks part. The picks aside, it is a clear no.