Boesch or Reimold

[price]

12 team AL only 5x5 roto w/obp $260 keeper

Who would you rather have

Boesch $5 (1yr) or Reimold $10 (2yr)

I was thinking of offering my Reimold for him plus my B.Allen and some res picks. Boesch is $5 less and I can add a yr at $5 more or take him in at $5, save the money for the draft and I could trade him later to someone and they could add a yr if they wanted.

I just picked up some salary (see my other thread) and thought this might be worth a try. I think Boesch could have a big year in that line up batting 2nd.

What do you guys think

Many thanks

[cool hand]

i think boesch and i dont think it's close.

[Porcello]

I really like both, but unfortunately only one organization likes their guy and that's Boesch. O's seem to be trying to find ways to not get Reimold AB's.

[joncarlos]

i think boesch and i dont think it's close.

I think I agree. I'd probably take Boesch straight up and he's also cheaper.

[price]

I think I agree. I'd probably take Boesch straight up and he's also cheaper.

How about my $10 Reimold (2yrs) for $9 D.Murphy (1yr)

Reason I ask is because I have Gentry at a $1 and it might make for a good combo for 2 of my OF spots. I think Reimold is going to be spliting time with Chavez.

We have to turn in our rosters Mon and haven't heard from the Boesch owner. I offered him 2 players for him

Should I just not bother and keep Reimold?

[virgonomic]

Murphy is a safer pick so I'd flip Reimold for him. Reimold does have upside so standing pat is not a terrible move.