Trade Granderson?

[moasis]

Would you do this trade? 10 team AL only 5X5 Auction league- 15 keepers: ( I would be giving up Granderson $26). Our Deadline is in 2 hours.

Austin Jackson $10, Mike Carp $6, Ervin Santana $18 and Addison Reed $3 for Curtis Granderson. I have room for all of them? My initial reaction is no. I was offered three young players last year for a $39 Crawford- I passed! I remember a ton of previous Granderson owners who have complained about him over the years. Does he keep it up?

[chancellor]

I wouldn't do it. Granderson will probably regress a bit, but he'll still earn well over $26 in a 10-team AL Only, IMO. Carp and Reed might have some profit in them, Jackson likely has a little, and Santana has none at best. The three keepers I'd be replacing would have to really, really suck for me to contemplate this deal.

[Sam]

The three keepers I'd be replacing would have to really, really suck for me to contemplate this deal.

That's the biggest part to me. I'd say no to the trade unless you really needed to improve the overall quality of your team and it needs a few parts. But I'd stand pat with Granderson

[moasis]

Would if Kipnis was subbed for Carp?

[moasis]

I did turn it down. Which was my first reaction. I do tend to over value my players sometimes so I needed to make sure. thanks for the opinions. The three keepers that they would fill would be empty slots. I only have 12 Keepers right now.