NL Only Keepers Help Needed

[Neilage]

4x4, $260, Max of 15 keepers

Any feedback would be greatly appreciated!!!

Geovany Soto $11
Greg Dobbs $10
Pablo Sandoval $20
Emilio Bonifacio $10
Jimmy Rollins $21
Brandon Phillips $25
Aramis Ramirez $24
Jay Bruce $38
Nate Schierholtz $10
Tony Campana $10
Bryan LaHair $10
Jonathan Lucroy $10
Jason Heyward $21

Yovani Gallardo $21
Tim Lincecum $32
Carlos Marmol $20
Jaime Garcia $5
Cory Luebke $10
Brian Wilson $21
Antonio Bastardo $10

[joncarlos]

How many teams?

Panda $20
Bonifacio $10
Phillips $25
Heyward $21 - yes I am still a believer

YoGa $21
Garcia $5
Luebke $10
Beard $21

That's 8... in most cases I am probably adding Aramis, and maybe Soto. I really don't know what to do with Marmol, my gut says he doesn't earn $20 but I think given the Cubs' pen he will have an exceptionally long leash. I think you can talk me into Rollins. Unsure about Lahair.

Definitely not Bruce, Schierholtz, Campana, Lucroy, Timmah, Bastardo.

[Gregg]

I would add Phillips to JC's list.

[scottw]

4x4, $260, Max of 15 keepers
**********= no brainers [10]
//////////////= think about it and probably do it [4]
Comes down to one of: Schierholz, LaHair, and Campana--or maybe save the roster spot?

Geovany Soto $11///////////? one of Soto or Lucroy
Greg Dobbs $10 no
Pablo Sandoval $20******************
Emilio Bonifacio $10*****************
Jimmy Rollins $21*******************
Brandon Phillips $25*****************
Aramis Ramirez $24 ******************
Jay Bruce $38 /////////lot of money, but terrific player--you know your league better than us--is this more than he would normally be bid?
Nate Schierholtz $10
Tony Campana $10
Bryan LaHair $10
Jonathan Lucroy $10 ////////////////? see Soto
Jason Heyward $21 *****************

Yovani Gallardo $21*************************
Tim Lincecum $32 ////////////see Jay Bruce
Carlos Marmol $20 ////////////I'm not a believer but you may be
Jaime Garcia $5 ***********************
Cory Luebke $10*************************
Brian Wilson $21 ************************
Antonio Bastardo $10----no--not much chance of saves w/ Papelbon a horse

[TS Garp]

I'd let Heyward go. I think he'll bounce back to some extent but will he really cost much more than $21? Assuming there are other good options, I'd ratherkeep Rollins and Aramis, who play at more scarce positions. Here's my list:

Geovany Soto $11
Pablo Sandoval $20
Emilio Bonifacio $10
Jimmy Rollins $21 (or Phillips if you prefer him at the slightly higher price)
Aramis Ramirez $24

Yovani Gallardo $21
Carlos Marmol $20
Jaime Garcia $5
Cory Luebke $10
Brian Wilson $21

[sfleming]

Here's my list :

Geovany Soto $11
Pablo Sandoval $20
Brandon Phillips $25
Jimmy Rollins $21
Aramis Ramirez $24
Emilio Bonifacio $10

Yovani Gallardo $21
Jaime Garcia $5
Cory Luebke $10
Brian Wilson $21

you'll still have a little room for a few top line OF at the draft.