Another keeper question.

[onejayhawk]

16 team H2H league, 8x8: Hits, OBA, SLG, L, Holds, IP

I can see I made this too detailed. Try this. I can keep Michael Cuddyer relatively cheap. Given that he plays 2B, should I:

1) also keep Dustin Pedroia and Adrian Beltre or
2) keep Beltre and Greinke/draft pick

J

[onejayhawk]

Come on guys. There are only two choices. Going into a draft/auction, would you rather have Pedroia, Beltre and Cuddyer or Beltre, Grienke and Cuddyer? Grienke is a reasonable approximation of the value of the first available players.

J

[Moonlight J]

No salaries or pick ramifications?

[Stephen]

It's very early, but I'd keep Pedroia, Beltre and Cuddyer.

Assuming off season trading is allowed I'd definitely shop Pedroia and Cuddyer around to see if I could get a worth offer to better diversify my keeper lists, but there are far worse ways to play in a 16 team league with Pedroia and Cuddyer as as your 2B/MI.

[virgonomic]

Agreed. Pedroia / Beltre / Cuddyer.

[onejayhawk]

No salaries or pick ramifications?

Not for this round. I have two players I can freeze, Beltre and Grienke. Either is at least as good as the likely available pick. My first real decision is whether Tabata is worth a round later than this.

J

[Gregg]

It's very early, but I'd keep Pedroia, Beltre and Cuddyer.

Assuming off season trading is allowed I'd definitely shop Pedroia and Cuddyer around to see if I could get a worth offer to better diversify my keeper lists, but there are far worse ways to play in a 16 team league with Pedroia and Cuddyer as as your 2B/MI.

I agree with this.