NL-Only 4x4 Keeper League - Hudson ($11-s2) for Maybin ($5-s1)

[YourPalChrisMal]

NL-Only 4x4 Keeper League with 20% inflation, all other things being equal, which would you rather have...

Daniel Hudson $11, s2
or
Cameron Maybin $5, s1

Maybin enters his option year, so you almost have to make him $10, I would think.

[schlesinj]

For you I would go after Maybin. You have a solid pitching staff. Hudson is a nice breakout candidate, but his main value is Ks.

[Hornsby]

NL-Only 4x4 Keeper League with 20% inflation, all other things being equal, which would you rather have...

Daniel Hudson $11, s2
or
Cameron Maybin $5, s1



Maybin enters his option year, so you almost have to make him $10, I would think.

I wouldn't go near Maybin at 10 bucks...if you decide to keep him, no way should you extend him. The risk is far too great...

[Gregg]

Hudson= stud

Maybin = bust

Hudson = stud

Maybin = bust

All kidding aside you should do much better if you want to trade Hudson.