AL 10 Team 5x5 Keeper Help Needed

[mike9289]

Can keep up to 11. My roster is:

JP Arencibia $2
A. Avila $1 In option year, can keep for $1 or extend for $5/year
J. Mathis $1
C. Davis $3
J. Smoak $10
M. Aviles $1
M. Scuturo $11 Option Year
Beltre $19
LaPorta $11
Moreland $2
Jennings $6
G. Blanco $3
T. Snider $7
V. Wells $14

Arieta $2 Option Year
Buchholz $12
Jake McGee $4
Carlos Carrasco $5
Fister $9
Holland $8
Morrow $1

I know a lot of these guys are about the same. Need some opinions. Thanks.

[Hornsby]

Can keep up to 11. My roster is:

JP Arencibia $2
A. Avila $1 In option year, can keep for $1 or extend for $5/year Keep
J. Mathis $1
C. Davis $3
J. Smoak $10
M. Aviles $1 Keep
M. Scuturo $11 Option Year
Beltre $19 Keep
LaPorta $11
Moreland $2
Jennings $6 Keep
G. Blanco $3
T. Snider $7 Keep
V. Wells $14Keep

Arieta $2 Option Year
Buchholz $12 Keep
Jake McGee $4 Keep
Carlos Carrasco $5 Keep
Fister $9
Holland $8
Morrow $1 Keep

I know a lot of these guys are about the same. Need some opinions. Thanks.

I'd keep Jennings just because he should come up sometime in June of July, IMO.

[chancellor]

JP Arencibia $2
A. Avila $1 In option year, can keep for $1 or extend for $5/year - Keep, but no extension.
J. Mathis $1
C. Davis $3 - Probably will be traded to the Cubs. If you get stats after a player is dealt, keep him.
J. Smoak $10
M. Aviles $1 - Keep
M. Scuturo $11 Option Year
Beltre $19 - Keep
LaPorta $11
Moreland $2
Jennings $6 - Keep
G. Blanco $3
T. Snider $7 - Keep
V. Wells $14 - Keep

Arieta $2 Option Year
Buchholz $12 - Keep
Jake McGee $4 - If you're a buy skills, not roles person, keep him. He could well end up as a MR this year, though
Carlos Carrasco $5 - Keep
Fister $9
Holland $8
Morrow $1 -- While I'm not as high on Morrow as others, you have to keep him for a buck in a 5x5 league.

[Gregg]

It is a keeper league. I do not understand how no one has picked Arencibia at 2 bucks. I like him over Davis and McGee. Big upside at bad position.

[mike9289]

It is a keeper league. I do not understand how no one has picked Arencibia at 2 bucks. I like him over Davis and McGee. Big upside at bad position.

Well I can keep 11 so I probably will throw JP in.
Surprised that Carasco was a unanimous KEEP and Smoak was a unanimous throw back. In a previous thread I mentioned Smoak at $10 in an AL league and everybody thought he was a definite keeper.

[virgonomic]

Well I can keep 11 so I probably will throw JP in.
Surprised that Carasco was a unanimous KEEP and Smoak was a unanimous throw back. In a previous thread I mentioned Smoak at $10 in an AL league and everybody thought he was a definite keeper.

I like JP over Avila.
Safeco is gonna sap Smoak's power. IF he hits consistently, I think you still have better options than a $10 Mark Grace.

[Rush]

I'm staying away from Smoak unless I have no choice, and then he'd have to be a buck or two. Don't know why anyone would want a power position guy who plays in Seattle or Oakland.

Arencibia $2 is certainly worth a flyer in the Rogers launching pad

[Teenwolf]

Same list as Horns, but drop Avila, add Arencibia.

Even if JPA flops, you NEED to take a $2 flier on the PCL MVP.

[mike9289]

Can keep up to 11. My roster is:

JP Arencibia $2
A. Avila $1 In option year, can keep for $1 or extend for $5/year
J. Mathis $1
C. Davis $3
J. Smoak $10
M. Aviles $1
M. Scuturo $11 Option Year
Beltre $19
LaPorta $11
Moreland $2
Jennings $6
G. Blanco $3
T. Snider $7
V. Wells $14

Arieta $2 Option Year
Buchholz $12
Jake McGee $4
Carlos Carrasco $5
Fister $9
Holland $8
Morrow $1

I know a lot of these guys are about the same. Need some opinions. Thanks.

Been offered a $7 Matusz, $4 Chris Carter and $1 Jepsen for Jennings $6. I also give up reserve draft picks, which aren't as valuable in this league as in others. Don't even think I will keep Carter or Jepsen; but is it worth it just to get Matusz.

[virgonomic]

Been offered a $7 Matusz, $4 Chris Carter and $1 Jepsen for Jennings $6. I also give up reserve draft picks, which aren't as valuable in this league as in others. Don't even think I will keep Carter or Jepsen; but is it worth it just to get Matusz.

Not while he's an Oriole. I think Jennings' value ceiling is higher.