Trumbo or Melkey?

[Gregg]

Who do you like better for this year and next. Trumbo $5a or Melkey Cabrera $6a?

AL only 5x5 ultra keeper.

Seems like Trumbo might have the higher upside, then again Melkey is having a career year.

[joncarlos]

Honestly I'd take Melky, I think we've already seen Trumbo's best. But it really depends on your needs, Trumbo could continue to be a .240-25HR guy if he has a place to play next year (I am guessing he will, but who knows). Melky probably won't do this again next year but he's doing well this year and gives you more balance.

[Ryno84MVP]

I believe that Melky is a free agent after this year, so who knows where he'll end up and what his role will be, and Trumbo has to deal with Kendrys Morales next year. I'm not really in love with either option if I'm looking toward next year, but I guess it depends on what you have to give-up. For this year, I'd probably go with Melky