which offer?

[DJRadar]

16-team, 6x6 (AVG, HR, R, RBI, SB-CS, BB-K and W, SV+HD, IP, K, ERA, WHIP)
$260 auction budget
$400 in-season cap
keep 6 major / 4 minor
+$3 first 3 years, +$6 after that

C - Perez $13
1B - Dalbec $4
2B - Biggio $11 2nd year keeper
3B - Moran $1
SS - Gopdrum $10
CI - India $5
MI - Chavis $5
OF - Taylor Ward $10
OF - Benintendi $5
OF - Renfroe $1
OF - Riley $15
DH - Kim $13
P - Nola $23 5th year keeper
P - Paddack $16 2nd year keeper
P - Singer $4 2nd year keeper
P - Houser $10
P - Wainwright $6
P - Whitlock $10
P - Iglesias $15
P - Devin Williams $15
P - Gregory Soto $5
BN - Marwin Gonzalez $5
BN - Moran $1
BN - Dozier $13
BN - Duffy $10
BN - Bubic $5
BN - Lester $10
BN - Daniel Hudson $5
DL - Mondesi $14 3rd year keeper
DL - Trout $55 9th year keeper
MN - Rutschman $10
MN - Manoah $3
MN - Brujan $1
MN - Nolan Jones $10

With Trout out 2 months, it's time to look forward to 2022. I have 2 offers:

Barnhart $10 and Hand $15 for Perez
Witt $1 and Synergaard $4/1st year for Riley and Nola

Thoughts from the RJ crowd? Who should I be shopping? And who should I be keeping for next year?

[Sharky]

I like the second one a lot. Witt and Thor for that price? All over it. Riley looks to have turned a corner, but still... Witt could be awesome and Thor is a nice piece. Nola will be at value.

If we knew Brujan was going to play 2B, I would say don’t worry about Biggio. Still, would be nice if you could upgrade 2B and CI. Most logical play is to move Trout once he comes back. A contender should want him and he is potentially keepable next year (though I probably wouldn’t). You also need top pitching; can you target a guy like Trevor Rogers?

[chancellor]

Deal 1 - Nope.

Deal 2 - I’d go for that. It’s risky, but Witt could be huge in a league like yours.

[revo]

Agree with Chance. In a BA league, Sal Perez has far more value than an OBP league.

I would take Deal 2. Witt could be a monster, and if you're throwing in the towel, getting those 2 makes sense.

[virgonomic]

Another vote for Deal #2. Thor will be back soon and you could even flip him this year if he looks good upon return.

[Gregg]

Another vote for Deal #2. Thor will be back soon and you could even flip him this year if he looks good upon return.

Me too. But I am not flipping a $4 Thor.

[virgonomic]

Me too. But I am not flipping a $4 Thor.

What about a post-TJ Thor? Suppose Eloy's owner is going for it and offers him?