Upgrading Keepers in AL League

[Sharky]

Trying to upgrade my last keeper in an AL 5x5 12-team league. Before I get into the situation, how do you rank these guys and how close are they to each other?

Jorge Soler $17
Teoscar Hernandez $13
Clint Frazier $6

Soler and Frazier are final year. Hernandez has one year before his option year (so option in 2022). I have one of the three already; didn’t want to bias the feedback by revealing.

Thanks!

[virgonomic]

Teoscar Hernandez $13
Jorge Soler $17
Clint Frazier $6

Teo vs. Jorge is a coin flip. Jorge won't hit 48 HR but he should get into a better groove than 2020. Still, I'll take Teo who is a bit more predictable.

I think Frazier's ceiling is pretty low and he's pretty much been an extension of his minor league stats.

[Sharky]

Teoscar Hernandez $13
Jorge Soler $17
Clint Frazier $6

Teo vs. Jorge is a coin flip. Jorge won't hit 48 HR but he should get into a better groove than 2020. Still, I'll take Teo who is a bit more predictable.

I think Frazier's ceiling is pretty low and he's pretty much been an extension of his minor league stats.

Thanks! I have Soler but like the idea of saving some $$ for the auction. Teoscar appeals for the extra year of control - he could have trade value. The others won’t. Helpful to know you like Soler though. Surprised to hear you’re down on Frazier like that however.

[Sharky]

Got the deal done for Teoscar. Toronto playing lots of games in Dunedin and Buffalo. That should really help HR and counting stats IMO.

[virgonomic]

Thanks! I have Soler but like the idea of saving some $$ for the auction. Teoscar appeals for the extra year of control - he could have trade value. The others won’t. Helpful to know you like Soler though. Surprised to hear you’re down on Frazier like that however.

I see his ceiling as 20 HR 80 RBI guy. There is profit for $6 but I like Teoscar better. Didn't even think about him playing in DUN/BUF as you mentioned.

[Sharky]

Thanks Virgo. Got the trade done. Gave Soler and a minor league pick for Teoscar and a lesser pick (same round). Excited!

[virgonomic]

Thanks Virgo. Got the trade done. Gave Soler and a minor league pick for Teoscar and a lesser pick (same round). Excited!

Good luck!