Happ or Dickerson?

[whalewang]

9-team NL-only 5x5 keeper league.

My team's offense is very balanced atm. Do you keep Happ or Dickerson for one of my OF slots (both at $8). Or a $1 Franchy Cordero?

[Judge Jude]

Cordero no because it's a 9-team. only about 45-50 OFs on rosters, so basically only starters get chosen. as of now, no way Franchy goes for more than 1 - and does he get drafted at all?

him clogging your freeze list is an "opportunity cost."

they all might be, but the other two are borderline with your parameters. I'd lean C-Dick, because it seems like he has a better path to regular time.

[chancellor]

If I had to choose today, Dickerson. I think Happ will win CF, but Almora has looked pretty strong so far trying to win the CF job.

[Ken]

Dickerson

[joncarlos]

Dickerson is really good and they're moving the fences in. I think he'll have a good year. Happ is a true wild card. I guess I'd take the sure thing in Dickerson.

[cavebird]

Dickerson or neither. Depends on how your league does things, but the Dickerson/Happ tier is usually the one that goes under-value in my auctions. The NL-only 9-team is a bit weird, so I don't know how deep that gets, but Dickerson or nobody. No reason to keep Happ.

[Sour Masher]

I say Dickerson too, but feel compelled to say Happ wasn't bad when he started last year. I wouldn't mind getting him cheap and taking a flyer on him.