Dynasty league: Goldschmidt or Matt Chapman?

[onejayhawk]

Their current ADP are 6th round for Goldschmidt and 7th/8th round for Chapman. For Dynasty leagues, is the age difference worth it?

Steamer

Goldschmidt .273/.369/.494, 31 HR, 91 R, 91 RBI, age 32
Matt Chapman .257/.343/.510, 34 HR, 95 R, 97 RBI, age 26

[joncarlos]

I wanted more from Goldy in STL. Was it just a 1-year adjustment or is he slipping? Chapman is so much younger that I think I'd lean towards him.

[Sour Masher]

Chapman for me. Goldy had a great run, and his second half shows he still has some left in the tank, but I think the days of him being a round 1 or 2 talent are over. Chapman will be really good for years to come. And he is a joy to watch defensively, if that matters to you at all .

[chancellor]

Chapman for me as well. The glove matters since it means he'll stay at 3B.