Trade for Kinsler and Dunn?

[Northern Lights]

14 team/H2H/no keepers


I have been offered Kinsler and Adam Dunn for my Nolasco, Big Papi, Arrieta and Aaron Hill.

Kinsler would slot in for Hill, while Dunn would slot in for Ortiz.

Are Kinsler and Dunn worthwhile buy-lows here, or is tossing him Nolasco to "upgrade" those positions a bad idea?

Arrieta is a non-factor, as I feel he is pretty much replacement level.

My pitching would consist of Pineda, Billingsley, Kennedy, Stauffer, Gallardo and Lilly + stream options after the trade.

I'd use the extra roster spots to stream starters most likely.

Thanks for the help!

[joncarlos]

I don't like it. I like Kinsler >>> Hill but I think Dunn is just looking horrendous right now and I'd rather have Papi by a mile. Dunn has a 41% k rate. 41 percent! And his HR/FB is way down despite playing in The Cell now.

[virgonomic]

Agreed. I like the structure of the deal but you need a better hitter than Dunn: someone along the lines of a Beltre, Quentin, etc.