Rank these SP 1 through 6?

[Neilage]

NL Only, 4X4 (No Ks) $260:

Going into my 29th auction in an extremely deep keeper league.

How would you rank these SP 1 through 6?

I don't really care about ADP as much as I do ROI.

The following hurlers are available in the FA pool, and I am hoping to come out of the auction with 3 of them:

Alex Reyes
Dakota Hudson
Jhoulys Chacin
Jimmy Nelson
Freddy Peralta
Anibal Sanchez

Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.

[B-Fly]

Chacin
Sanchez
Peralta
Reyes
Hudson
Nelson

[Sour Masher]

Chacin
Sanchez
Peralta
Reyes
Hudson
Nelson

Wow, no Nelson love. The names above him have upside, but Nelson does have a job....that is worth something. I'd put him above Hudson and Peralta (who I like a lot, but they don't seem to want him to start for some reason).

[B-Fly]

Wow, no Nelson love.

Often hurt, often just not good.

[joncarlos]

Nelson
Chacin
---
Reyes (even assuming he's a reliever)
Anibal
---
Peralta
Hudson

[Hornsby]

NL Only, 4X4 (No Ks) $260:

Going into my 29th auction in an extremely deep keeper league.

How would you rank these SP 1 through 6?

I don't really care about ADP as much as I do ROI.

The following hurlers are available in the FA pool, and I am hoping to come out of the auction with 3 of them:

Alex Reyes
Dakota Hudson
Jhoulys Chacin
Jimmy Nelson
Freddy Peralta
Anibal Sanchez

Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.

If it's a keeper league, I'd got with Reyes at the top...sooner or later, the odds say that he's got to get/stay healthy for a period of time. I'd discount Nelson at this point, since he was supposed to be back last year by mid-season, he has to prove it. No fan of Freddie Peralta, but I do like Sanchez and Chacin, but nearer th bottom of your list. How's that for confusing jumble?

[The Dane]

I'd put them like this:

Alex Reyes
~
~
Anibal Sanchez
Freddy Peralta
~
Jhoulys Chacin
Jimmy Nelson
~
Dakota Hudson

Okay. ALL of these guys have substantial risk of both skills implosion and injury, so let's set that aside. Reyes is, by a wide mile, the best pitcher on this list. He has the best skill set, the highest upside, plays on the best team, and in a decent park for SPs. It's not close for me. He's #1 on this list very easily.

After that, it gets a little tighter. Those next four are, in effect, four versions of the same pitcher: iffy starters with dubious history and little job security, except that Peralta/Chacin/Nelson all play for a team that needs them so bad.

Hudson feels, to me, to be a man without a role. Maybe he'll be stuck in middle relief.

[DMT]

Agree with Dane

[Sour Masher]

Today it was announced Paralta will get a shot in the rotation. Maybe he is the one bumped when Nelson gets back. IDK. But I agree with Dane that Reyes is light years ahead of the rest in terms of raw pitching stuff. Peralta is second to be, though.nhe could run with this chance.