Mixed League Keepers due this Sunday - Suggestions welcomed!

[MagSeven]

14 team Mixed, 5x5, $300 cap. Madducks and Mith are in this league also. This team finished second to Mith last year and I'm determined to beat him in 2018.
We can keep 9. Numbers in parentheses are salaries for (2018,19,20)

Zunino (1,6,11)
Votto (38,43)
Bruce (3,8,13)
LoMo (1,6,11)
Starlin Castro (2,7,12)
Jorge Polanco (1,6,11)
LeMahieu (6,11)
Andrus (1,6,11)
Hamilton (44,49,54)
Gardner (1,6,11)
Souza (1,6,11)
Kluber (51,56,61)
CMart (11)
Quintana (32,37,42)
Pomeranz (5,10,15)
Chad Green (1,6,11)
J Montgomery (1,6,11)
Giles (22)
B Parker (1,6,11)
Chapman (27,32)

Stud hitters and pitchers are extremely expensive. Any thoughts and suggestions would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance!

[Pauly]

are you locked into the three years if you keep them?

[revo]

Zunino (1,6,11)
Votto (38,43)
Bruce (3,8,13)
LoMo (1,6,11)
Starlin Castro (2,7,12)
Jorge Polanco (1,6,11)
LeMahieu (6,11)
Andrus (1,6,11)
Hamilton (44,49,54)
Gardner (1,6,11)
Souza (1,6,11)
Kluber (51,56,61)
CMart (11)
Quintana (32,37,42)
Pomeranz (5,10,15)
Chad Green (1,6,11)
J Montgomery (1,6,11)
Giles (22)
B Parker (1,6,11)
Chapman (27,32)


My 2 cents. How do you have Andrus for $1?

[Mithrandir]

Zunino (1,6,11)
Votto (38,43)
Bruce (3,8,13)
LoMo (1,6,11)
Starlin Castro (2,7,12)
Jorge Polanco (1,6,11)
LeMahieu (6,11)
Andrus (1,6,11)
Hamilton (44,49,54)
Gardner (1,6,11)
Souza (1,6,11)
Kluber (51,56,61)
CMart (11)
Quintana (32,37,42)
Pomeranz (5,10,15)
Chad Green (1,6,11)
J Montgomery (1,6,11)
Giles (22)
B Parker (1,6,11)
Chapman (27,32)


My 2 cents. How do you have Andrus for $1?

No Kluber??? The league doesn't have MI or CI so Andrus wasn't real sought after last year.

[Mithrandir]

are you locked into the three years if you keep them?

Not locked in.

[Mithrandir]

Zunino (1,6,11)
Votto (38,43)
Bruce (3,8,13)
LoMo (1,6,11)
Starlin Castro (2,7,12)
Jorge Polanco (1,6,11)
LeMahieu (6,11)
Andrus (1,6,11)
Hamilton (44,49,54)
Gardner (1,6,11)
Souza (1,6,11)
Kluber (51,56,61)
CMart (11)
Quintana (32,37,42)
Pomeranz (5,10,15)
Chad Green (1,6,11)
J Montgomery (1,6,11)
Giles (22)
B Parker (1,6,11)
Chapman (27,32)

[Gregg]

Zunino (1,6,11)
Votto (38,43)
Bruce (3,8,13)
LoMo (1,6,11)
Starlin Castro (2,7,12)
Jorge Polanco (1,6,11)
LeMahieu (6,11)
Andrus (1,6,11)
Hamilton (44,49,54)
Gardner (1,6,11)
Souza (1,6,11)
Kluber (51,56,61)
CMart (11)
Quintana (32,37,42)
Pomeranz (5,10,15)
Chad Green (1,6,11)
J Montgomery (1,6,11)
Giles (22)
B Parker (1,6,11)
Chapman (27,32)

This is $66 spent with out Kluber. Does it make sense to keep the $32 Quintana over Kluber and rebid Kluber at the auction?

[Mithrandir]

This is $66 spent with out Kluber. Does it make sense to keep the $32 Quintana over Kluber and rebid Kluber at the auction?

Maybe. I can see Kluber going for $60+. Am I under valuing Quintana?

So where's your choices Gregg?

[Gregg]

Maybe. I can see Kluber going for $60+. Am I under valuing Quintana?

So where's your choices Gregg?

With the exception of my Kluber/Quintana question. I think I agree with you on the rest.

[MagSeven]

Andrus was an 'end of the draft' $1 claim. I'm leaning towards these keepers:
Votto 38
Bruce 3
LeMahieu 6
Andrus 1
Kluber 51
CMart 11
Pom 5
LoMo/Souza/Gardner as finalists for my last 2

[chancellor]

I'd dump Pomeranz and keep all three of the hitters.

[Gregg]

I'd dump Pomeranz and keep all three of the hitters.

Hmm...Good call.

Keeping Kluber I am going with chance's great suggestion.

[Sour Masher]

Yeah, Pom scares me a bit. I'd keep Klu-bot as well. Dude's a machine.

[cavebird]

I'd keep all of the last three you list and throw back Kluber. If he goes for $60, that's only $9, or more likely you can get another stud pitcher for that price unless the inflation is insane. While I think his suggestions look fine, I would always take advice from the competition with more than a few grains of salt, lol.

[cavebird]

I can see keeping Kluber and dumping Pomz, too. It is safer.